Former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton is facing criticism after comments on MSNBC’s Morning Joe on Wednesday, in which she appeared to equate Christian conservatism with efforts to turn back progress in the United States.
Speaking with hosts Joe Scarborough and Mika Brzezinski, Clinton praised the nation as a “work in progress”.
Still, he warned against what she described as attempts to recreate a past dominated by “white men of a certain persuasion, a certain religion, a certain point of view, a certain ideology.”
“We haven’t gotten to the more perfect union,” Clinton said. “And people have been protesting for hundreds of years that things were not as they should be…”
“And the idea that you could turn the clock back and try to recreate a world that never was—dominated by, let’s say it, White men of a certain persuasion, certain religion, a certain point of view, a certain ideology—it is just doing such damage to what we should be aiming for.”
Clinton added that such efforts were “doing such damage to what we should be aiming for.”
She ironically urged Americans to “stop demonizing each other” but immediately attributed most of the division to the political right. Clinton falsely argued that conservatives seek to dominate the public square and whitewash historical realities such as slavery.
WATCH:
Clinton’s remarks came two weeks after the assassination of conservative activist Charlie Kirk, a leading figure in Christian conservatism, who was gunned down at Utah Valley University on Sept. 10.
The exchange came during a broader conversation about whether the United States could overcome polarization.
Clinton contrasted the idea of national progress with what she sees as the dangers of nostalgia for an imagined past.
She also criticized Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. for what she called a retreat to a time when “we aren’t vaccinating, we’re drinking raw milk, yeah, and people didn’t live.”
Her comments touched a nerve because of the timing. Kirk, 31, had been an outspoken defender of Christianity, often clashing with progressives over race, faith, and the role of religion in public life.
His assassination, which prosecutors allege was carried out by 22-year-old Tyler Robinson, shocked the conservative movement and prompted an outpouring of tributes from allies including former President Donald Trump.
Clinton’s words quickly circulated on social media, where critics accused her of targeting Christians in general and white Christian men in particular.
Conservative commentator Jack Posobiec, a friend of Kirk, argued that her remarks would be understood by “the violent left” as a signal to target the same demographic Kirk represented.
Others pointed to Clinton’s past statements, such as her 2023 suggestion that supporters of Trump might require “formal deprogramming,” as evidence of a consistent hostility toward conservatives.
Kirk’s death has already fueled broader political debates.
Trump has pledged to seek federal investigations into groups he accuses of enabling political violence, while his administration has considered measures to revoke the tax-exempt status of organizations linked to extremism.
As Clinton’s remarks continue to draw attention, they highlight how the assassination of a conservative leader has become a new flashpoint in the culture wars.
Whether intended or not, her criticism of “white men of a certain persuasion” has been interpreted by many as a direct shot at the Christian conservative movement Kirk embodied—deepening divides at a moment when leaders across the spectrum are calling for unity.