One of the most horrific crimes in recent memory was the August stabbing of 23-year-old Iryna Zarutska. A young Ukrainian refugee just trying to build a new life, Zarutska was heading home after her shift at a pizza shop in Charlotte, N.C., when she boarded the city’s light rail.
She sat down in front of Decarlos Brown Jr., a man who — without reason, without provocation — stabbed her to death. She bled out on the floor of a train in the very city that had welcomed her.
And yet, this tragedy is far too familiar. Americans in Charlotte and across the nation are sick and tired of watching the justice system bend over backwards to “understand” criminals while treating victims like afterthoughts. We coddle repeat offenders, excuse violent behavior, and put the so-called “rights” of criminals above the safety of ordinary citizens.
Enough. The people of Charlotte are right to demand accountability, because if a young woman fleeing war can’t find safety here, what does that say about us?
More than 11,000 people have already signed a petition to remove North Carolina Magistrate Judge Teresa Stokes — and with good reason. Despite Brown Jr.’s long record of mental illness and 14 prior convictions, Stokes made the reckless decision to cut him loose in January after he was arrested for abusing the 911 system.
It has been 31 days since Iryna Zarutska’s murder, and the magistrate judge who freed her murderer prior to the crime is STILL on the bench.
Magistrate Judge Teresa Stokes MUST be removed immediately for failing her duty and losing public trust. pic.twitter.com/Go3HOnufjr
— Rep. Mark Harris (@RepMarkHarrisNC) September 23, 2025
No bail, no real accountability — just a flimsy “written promise” that he’d come back to court. That decision didn’t just fail the justice system, it failed the public — and it ultimately cost an innocent young woman her life.
“Why was a mentally ill, repeat offender allowed to walk free in Charlotte? After his most recent arrest — before he killed Iryna — Decarlos was released without bail by Magistrate Judge Teresa Stokes,” the petition states in part.
“According to North Carolina lawmakers, Judge Stokes released him ‘based solely on his written promise to appear for a future court date.’ Judge Stokes reviewed Decarlos’s lengthy criminal record, and possibly his history of mental illness, and still let him walk. We need answers and accountability,” it says.
The outrage isn’t just coming from ordinary citizens. Members of North Carolina’s Republican congressional delegation are also demanding Judge Teresa Stokes be removed. And they’re right to do so. Stokes’ reckless choice to let Decarlos Brown walk free on nothing more than a hollow “promise” to show up later is indefensible.
That single act of judicial negligence didn’t just embolden a career criminal — it paved the way for tragedy. Accountability isn’t optional when a judge’s poor judgment puts innocent lives at risk.
The delegation’s letter to Mecklenburg County Chief District Court Judge Roy Wiggins states in part:
Ms. Zarutska’s murder was not only a profound personal tragedy but also a direct result of a failure of judicial responsibility. By releasing a repeat violent offender on nothing more than his written promise to appear, Magistrate Stokes displayed a willful failure to perform the duties of her office and engaged in conduct prejudicial to the administration of justice.
The release of Decarlos Brown alone should have been enough to raise serious doubts about Judge Stokes’ fitness for the bench. But it gets worse.
Here’s another jaw-dropping fact: in North Carolina, magistrates aren’t even required to hold a law degree or pass the bar. Let that sink in. They can preside over cases, make decisions that determine freedom or incarceration, and in some cases decide life-or-death outcomes — yet more than 80 percent of them have never been to law school.
Stokes is hardly an outlier; she’s the product of a broken system that values paperwork and “experience” over genuine legal expertise. If reform is going to start anywhere, this is ground zero.